Self Made Series Q&A
Central Generosity
Description
After wrapping up our teaching series on Self Made, we sat down with series co-creators Haley Barinowski, Scofield Foster, and Blake Payne to ask some follow-up questions. They expound on topics like healthy emotion and ambition, the most prevalent self made song in our church, performance mentality in serving, singleness, and more.
- God has emotions and created us in his image as emotional beings, but we have to learn self awareness and ask if our emotions are aligned with God’s.
- Individualism in our society is only creating more anxiety, but engaging in the local church teaches us how to be part of something bigger than ourselves.
- The takeaways of the Self Made series can be summarized in these questions: Do I believe that God’s design for my life is the best possible life for me? And when my desires come in conflict with God’s design, who wins: me or God?
- Self Made series page
- The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self by Carl Trueman
- Strange New World by Carl Trueman
- The Secret Place of Thunder by John Starke
- Fighting Shadows by Jefferson Bethke and Jon Tyson
- Remade: Embracing Your Complete Identity in Christ devotional by Paul Tautges
- An Update to The Anxious Generation with Jonathan Haidt, The Russell Moore Show
- Scripture: Isaiah 5:12, 2 Peter 1:3
Really, everything we've covered in this self-made series, I think is back to Do I believe that the life God has asked us to live is actually the best life a human can live? Or do I not? Welcome to a special edition of the Members Podcast. Today we are answering questions that have come out of our self-made series. Last weekend we finished A5 part series addressing the cultural pressures to be self-made men and women. Today we have Hayley Baranowski, Blake Payne and Scofield Foster Co, creators of the sermon series, in for a follow up.
They're answering your questions ranging from the healthy role of emotions, the challenge of performance driven culture, sex, singleness and practical ways to sing better songs. If you missed any of the series teaching, you can find easy access on the Grace Church app or on our website at Grace dot SC under resources. I hope you enjoy.
So our first question reads like this. When it comes to our feelings and emotions, we tend to swing on a pendulum from my feelings don't really matter and so I should have void them completely. Two, my feelings are the only thing that matter and everyone else has to acknowledge them.
So the question is, what is the role of healthy emotion for us as believers? I will kick us off. Yes, I do care a lot about this topic just because even in preparing this last summer, I raised the question just about as we mature in our faith, is there the chance that not all of our feelings are bad all the time? I think we have to start at the perspective that we can't trust ourselves. We got to acknowledge our hearts are deceitful, but as we walk with the Lord longer, is there a chance our feelings shift And you know, can we, can we trust anything we're feeling or nothing at all?
So I think as we talked about it and I've had a year to kind of think on it a little bit more, I think there definitely is a role for feelings ultimately, just because God made them. So I don't think he would have made something innately that was all the way bad all the time. So I think we just have to be willing to evaluate them because they can't be deceitful.
So I think we see in God that he communicates with emotion too. So we see him communicate with anger and grief and joy and pride and, you know, the full range of emotions throughout Scripture. And that's not even taking into account the emotions that Jesus felt when he was on the earth.
So I think the ultimate question is, are we willing to vet them when we feel them? Do we know enough about the character and the instructions of God to have a standard to compare them to? And then are we willing to do so? And then over time, are we noticing hopefully that our emotions are starting to align with the way that God demonstrates emotion?
So are the things that make us angry, the things that make God angry are the things that make us sad, the things that make him sad and then, you know, extend that all the circumstances you can think of. So, so if we're made in God's image and God has emotion, then we have to have emotion. And so the question is healthy emotion and the self-awareness to discern that. And if, as we are being conformed and transformed into the image of Christ, those emotions should come into alignment. Yeah, hopefully over time.
But because it's such a powerful thing, it's easy to be deceived by it. Is that true? Yeah, absolutely. Well, if you think about it, I mean, if you looked at the Bible and you look for all the ways that you see God's emotions described, that'd be a fun kind of study to see how many, how many are there even? I mean, jealousy, anger, sadness, delight, leisure, love, I mean, interesting.
But I think again, like Haley said, the goal is that our feelings are in alignment with God 'cause God's feelings are always in alignment with reality and ours due to the broken nature of our hearts, like we see in Jeremiah 17, often aren't. And but to your point, the like the sanctification process should be one in which like there's this up and to the right movement of our emotions lined up with gods. But you know, like you were saying earlier, even that not all the way until he comes back and he finishes this work with us. So community, you know, the Scriptures, all that's always going to have a role to play.
But alignment, what does our feelings do? Our desires align with God's feelings and God's desires. One more thought on that. I was thinking, because we've been doing some work in the Old Testament downtown this summer, just that what it seems as you look through different Old Testament stories, especially in the era of the patriarchs, it does seem that God actually really values emotional engagement with his people. Because we've been looking at, you know, Abraham and Jacob and David and just the fact that I don't think God ever wanted us to be robots.
Like he wants a lifelong covenantal, committed relationship with us. And when emotion is a part of that, I think that actually brings joy to him because it's not this sterile, you know, I'm checking boxes because you told me to. It's that my heart is engaged in my relationship with you, too.
And so I don't think God ever desires for our emotions to go away. I think they just have to be redirected over time. But actually think he loves that we have them and he wants us to engage with him in them, whether it's, you know, emotion actually about our faith or about whatever we have going on. Yeah. And there was another thought around ambition. How?
How is that? And the emotion of wanting to achieve or be recognized or or be productive, How, how does that play into this conversation? I think very similarly, and this one is near to my heart too, because I do think that can actually be a pretty strong driving factor. I think there are emotions attached with that, whether it's identity and purpose and value. I think we when you are driven by ambition, you associate a lot of feelings with that.
But I think the solution or the approach is actually pretty similar because I don't think God looks down upon ambition per SE. I think if we look even in the way that he interacted with his people over time, he didn't necessarily look down upon or discourage success. I mean, even in a worldly sense at times, like we see it in the life of Joseph and of David too, that over different portions of their lives, it says that God was with them and everything they did prospered.
So I think if they had not brought at least something of their personality to those efforts, that something could have been lost there. But I do think you also see in plenty of other examples that when ambition is removed from God and it's something that you're exercising or going after apart from God, that it's purely selfish. So really, I don't, I don't think it's actually all that different from emotions. I think it's just a willingness to vet them. And then when it comes to a conflict between me and God in terms of what I'm going after, what I'm feeling, how I'm wanting to respond to a feeling, what I'm trying to pursue, who is it that I'm going to respond to?
Is it me or is it God? Yeah. And I do think there's a gap in the way we think about work and we're actually working, working on a podcast where we try to bring some some better faith integration in the way that we talk about work.
So you can just be on the lookout for that. If we zoom out for a second, Blake, and just think about big picture, these self-made ideas, which one do you think has made it most or is most prevalent into the belief of the members of Grace Church? Well, just even going off of what Haley and Scofield said, one thing I'm encouraged by if I can start there. Please, is that OK? Yes. OK.
One thing I'm encouraged by is I think even as we are opening the floodgate, so to speak, on some complicated issues, as we've talked through this, it feels like one of the overwhelming reactions is just humility around what ways might these lies be in me. And so that's super encouraging as I talk to people and hear about conversations.
Like I had a guy come up to me after one of these, one of Schofield sermons, and which I don't know why he came up after Schofield sermons, but he just came up to me and was just being honest about some things that he was learning and how he had seen some of the pressure of the world get inside of him. He was just responding to the topics. So I've been super encouraged by a willing, a church that's willing to not separate from, but be honest about.
And so I, I think that's been super encouraging. Because it is easy for for church to go US versus them. Yeah, inside the culture. Outside the culture, yeah, it's easy. For us to do US versus them inside the church. 100%, yeah. You know, Yeah, that's great.
Jesus talked about that I think somewhere. And so, but to answer the question, I would say I do think that as I've been just listening, it feels like couple weeks ago on Schofield walk through just main character syndrome. Just the idea that the most important part about me is me, you know, just individualism really at its finest. I think that really is pervasive and I don't think it's always malicious. I don't even know if it's always conscious, but I do think deep in our subconscious, we live in a culture that tells you to prioritize yourself above all.
And I feel that when people are coming into our church, how they're thinking about community and serving. And I feel that in me when I think about community and serving. You know, it's just, I think it's pervasive. I think it's deep within us and I think it has some real liabilities when we are operating as a bunch of individuals because Jesus didn't die for us to be individuals that come to the same building, right? He came he died for us to be a family, a place where we are not the most important thing, but we're meaningful as good as I talked about in that talk, but that we're connected to the most important thing.
And it's interesting. We wrapped with anxiety. And as I was writing some of that that talk, I've, I found some some research around anxiety and this guy was actually kind of zooming out and looking at the trends of international anxiety, not just in the States, but internationally. And there was really two categories that stuck out in the last few years that experienced little to no increase in anxiety and depression. And one of those categories was religious countries.
So actually Eastern Europe. Yeah, Eastern Europe was one of out of all the categories of Europe, Eastern Europe with Orthodox religion experienced less increase in anxiety and depression and some of that is connected to the second group which was Japan and Korea, which is interesting. Japan and Korea was not because of religion, but in Japan and Korea, like your last name is more important than your first name.
And so I think what you find in both of those is just the idea that I am not the most important thing, but I'm actually connected to something better. Even my last name, even having a a healthy pride and a healthy identity and something that's not Blake but it's a family. It does seem to be that that produces a lot of freedom. And I think that is what Jesus has in view for us when he dies for the church.
So I just think that if we as a church can just think about that and find ways to fight individualism, I think we will be more free. I think we'll be more healthy, and I think we will be less self-made. Yeah, yeah. No, thanks for sharing and I appreciate the encouragement. We'll we'll call you Barnabas. Sure from now on, I'll take it.
And, you know, I, I, I think about that faith being a team sport. You know, some people identify as the family, some people identify as the team sport. But I think you're right. Baked in is this idea of individuality.
So I even think of myself as a Christian when really that term was used to describe a group of people that were living a certain way. And we've reversed that. You know, we read the New Testament letters individually instead of reading them as a church.
And so you're, you're 100% right. It is, it is baked in. Schofield, can I ask you a question? Going all the way back, I believe the week 1 you were quoting from the Library of Congress. The true Shekinah is man. Then you describe that using Second Chronicles 7 talks about the glorious presence of God.
As believers though, we do bear the glorious presence of God within us through the Holy Spirit. And so the question is how do we receive the honor and glory that God has given us as image bearers and Co heirs with Christ but still stay inside the box that God has given us? What are your thoughts on that?
Yeah, I think it's a good point because it is worth noting. I mean, you get into chapter one of the Bible and you see that God creates the world, and then this pinnacle of his creation project is something that he makes in his own image unlike anything else he makes, and that is man. So you could say the true Shekinah's man, or the true most visible manifestation of God's glorious presence on earth is, well, man. And that's true. And I do think that's important to teach on and have a robust vision on around as we, you know, teach and disciple as a church, as we parent our children that we have a purpose, we have dignity, we have value and that is significant.
Like we have significance. And so there's a lot needed there. There's a lot needed to just color in the lines for us on what that means and how that changes things. And I've, I've been doing some listening and reading lately about the next generation of boys particularly, and how like they don't understand their why they exist as our part of our like society has been become so individualistic and fragmented and digital, we've been disconnected. And of course, you know, there's a whole conversation there around specifically the masculine experience and how we're trying to get rid of toxic masculinity feels like we kind of wiped away masculinity all together.
So then the boys are kind of like, so just don't be that. What am I supposed to be? And so then you should be able to insert in, well, you're an image bearer. You were created to be a, you know, a little mini king or queen to represent God's will and exercise dominion over the earth, to rule, to reign.
So I do want to say that I think the reason we're talking about that quote in this context is there's another side to that perspective that says not just that I have significance, but I create my own significance. And there's no outside source that provides that for me. It's something that I've determined, and I'm in competition with everybody else around me to, you know, to reach as much and create as much of that as I can. And speaking as a person who has dealt with those demons, it's bad. Yeah, it's a lot of pressure.
Yeah. It's just when you think about yourself as the center of the universe again, at first it it feels like it scratches an itch until you live that out and you realize how that's actually terrible. I'd rather have something better and be a part of something bigger. It's funny, even in culture, we were talking about this the other day. I think podcast culture maybe I was talking about this with you, Scott, just that one of the one of the, it seems like one of the goals of podcast is insight. Was that you?
OK. But that's very different than wisdom. 100. Percent taking those thoughts and ideas and applying. It's funny, if you just look at the culture, I mean, how many famous people were just dropping like flies? Like everything. Everybody kind of knows we can't really bear the weight, but are we really taking that principle and letting it change us?
You know, I think that's a question I have as you're walking through some of that. Yeah, and you did a good job in in your last sermon just talking about the logical conclusion of all that weight and all that pressure is a ton of anxiety and just loneliness. Scofield staying with you, when you talked about main character syndrome, you brought up the idea of the the John the Baptists in John chapter 3, which is just a great story.
But here's the question. How can the church celebrate the John the Baptists so that we don't fall victim that thinking that we all need to be main characters and and reinforce that stereotype in the church. Yeah, is it First Corinthians? Help me out, guys, 1213 talking about spiritual gifts and not despising those that don't get as much public honor. Yeah, that's right. OK, so that I think is a good starting point to say, hey, God's giving out gifts.
They represent his power, his glory, his agenda, his priorities. And they look different and but they're all reflection of him. But, you know, and so I remember hearing some older leaders in our our church talk about a guy that was serving with some of our facilities work. And you know, it's not the most public, you know, attention getting work that he was doing.
But they knew, they know him well enough and knew him well enough, knew kind of his character and just how he spent time in prayer and what he was doing as he walked around and did what the world would call like mundane, ordinary things. And they could see something in him that was very otherworldly, a level of contentment, A level of others focus, A level of goodness with his box. And like with spiritual eyes, they could see the power emanating from that.
And so they would joke in a loving way and talk about how when we get to heaven, well, he's going to be like the king of the country that we're living in. We'll go say, hey, can we come visit your castle? Because the honor that you're going to get out of your quiet service of faithfulness and the power of prayer in the ministry far outweighs this may be more public, traditional view of what, you know, meaningful giftedness and work and influence can look like.
And so that captures my imagination to say, if we could have spiritual glasses on and see how God sees, see how the spiritual realm sees, how would that change the nature of power and meaning and things that God sees that our world doesn't even value? And then how do we celebrate that, You know, how do we point out distinctive giftedness, personalities, attributes that God's given in someone? And first of all, it helps us practice self forgetfulness #1 #2 it helps us be a part of something bigger than just ourselves.
And it just starts to kill, I think, some of that main character syndrome that erodes our ability to be a part of something bigger and love and be thankful, you know? And I mean, and I think the truth is we, we, we could probably do a better job of telling those kinds of stories, celebrating those folks, even though those are the least people that want to be celebrated, but just holding them up as, as examples so that we see the full body, if you will, You know, that we see the hands and the feet and the head and the shoulders and all that, you know, because it does take, it does take everyone. And, and I think that there's so much emphasis on leading, which is important because we have a large church and we need people who are gifted to, to help keep people moving towards this goal of Christ likeness that sometimes slowing down and celebrating is not the easiest thing to do.
Yeah. Thinking about how some of these self-made ideas can be disguised in different forms. And we've said all along that the church is not immune to to, to any of these ideas.
So thinking about performance and a performance mentality, which is like you said earlier, Blake, is just, there's certain things that are deeply ingrained in us as a culture. But Haley, what does it look like when the performance mentality creeps in and shows up in the church and in the way that we think about ministry? Yeah, I don't think, unfortunately, the church is all that different than the culture sometimes. And I'm saying that as a, you know, a personal conviction, not a condemnation by any means.
I think we're human beings and when we struggle with stuff, we're going to bring it into whatever settings we're in, even if we're hopefully in the process of being redeemed out of it. I think anytime you are in a role that has way and is a need fills a need, especially if it's something that you're gifted in. And then especially on top of that, if it, if that's being validated and you're being affirmed for that being a gift of yours, I think it's nearly impossible to separate the performance mentality from it all the way.
And maybe that's just my sickness, but I think I share it with some people. It's, it's difficult, I think, because then you start, especially when you've got some good intentions too. You start wanting to make sure that in whatever role that you're serving the church, that you're doing a good job because it matters. And you want to honor the work that God has done in I'll save my own life. I want to translate that to other people in a way that is helpful. And I want them to feel impacted by, you know, the stories that God has told for years.
And so it's easy to want that so badly in such a good way that it slowly crosses over into I'm not OK if I don't do a good job. So I mean, I'll just answer transparently for, for how this has looked for me. My role serving has changed a lot over the past couple of years. And that has put me on a stage a lot more than I ever have been in my life to this point.
And so I have had to ask myself, Hopefully I'll, I'll continue to ask it more frequently. But to just be honest with myself and be willing to evaluate if this serving role, whatever you want to call it, if it went away forever, if I was never asked to teach again or if I didn't have a role in the church quote UN quote anymore #1 how would I feel about that? And #2 what would that do to like my one-on-one relationship with the Lord? What would that do to my prayer life? How would I feel about him?
Would I feel that he values me the same? Would I with the nature of my connection to God change at all? Because if I ask myself those questions and my serving role goes away, and my honest answer is that I'm not the same with the Lord as you know, as I feel like I am right now. I think that can raise a red. Flag. Then you would know the answer to that question.
Yes, because then I think you've started to kind of inappropriately merge how I'm serving, how I'm showing up at church, who knows what I'm doing there, who you know, how many people am I ministering to that starts to get into my relationship with God and and that's that's the commitment that I have made. That is the relationship that is my number one priority. And so nothing theoretically should change that, whether I have a serving role, whether I'm exercising my gifts in a public or private way, or whether I'm not, or if I'm in a situation where, you know, the need hasn't presented itself for my gifts right now.
And, and I'm just living my life with my fellow believers and with the Lord. So that's how I'm dealing with it right now. Yeah, I think that's good insight, to borrow a phrase from Blake. What do you think about that, Blake? Yeah, I think that's good. I mean, I don't have anything to add to what she sang.
A a couple funny things is I was thinking about when she was talking, you know, I come from the worship leader world. And so, you know, growing up in church, they would have this thing called the special. Y'all familiar? Oh yeah, you. Familiar with the special Scofield? I think so.
The special music so. Special music? You think so. You don't know. You like, you would just know, you know, which is the moment in the service where you know, Hilda gets that solo and she's been working on it for a long time. And, and what's funny is when I used to do worst auditions like you, just, it's one of the things you have to pay attention for is like, why are you wanting to sing?
Because when you sing, like you're very visible. And if you're talented, like it's just Haley's point, it's real easy to to mix all that up. And and so I think really even just being a worship leader, I learned how easy it is to get my identity wrapped up in my performance and to find life from it. And really, I can't lead people when I'm finding life from it. And I just, I agree with Haley too, that, I mean, it happens for me too. I think one of the things I've seen is to just be honest about it.
I think that's one of the helpful things just to be honest about when you're motives are getting sideways. I think you got to pay attention to it.
And I think that's really helpful. And if I can give a shout out, I'm really grateful for the leadership above me here just because you know, being in a, you know, somewhat upfront role, I think that can easily be a place where you get twisted. And for years now I've been grateful because there's obviously standards. We care about the Bible like you have to. We're, we're, we're trying. We're not not trying, we're trying.
But I've never felt this unnecessary pressure to be something that I'm not. But more so just a healthy pressure to be who I am and to, you know, pray, ask God what God is leading me to say and think about. And I'll never forget the first time I taught. I was just like, this was years ago. I mean, my stomach obviously was just in knots. And I go to Matt and he's outside of the student center.
And I'm like, I'm just, I'm looking for this nugget. Like, I'm waiting for this moment for him just to tell me to kind of validate my worry, you know, and tell me how important this is and give me this deep prayer. And he looked at me and he was like, yeah, man, go give your best shot. I'll clean it up next week. And he walked away and I just, I remember being a little stunned. I was like, does he not care more?
Like I could mess this whole thing up. And it just was one of the first moments of many that just was a little bit of a pressure relief to say, hey, you're actually not that important. Yeah, don't take yourself too seriously. You're not that important anyway. And seriously, if you mess up with, you know, we I'll fix it next week. It's fine.
And so that moment has is rung is rung loud in my head for for years. So I'm thankful for that because naturally, like Haley was saying, I do want to perform. I do like being liked.
And so I think just dying to all that and reminding yourself that this isn't about you anyway. Yeah. And you both mentioned we, I use the word perform. You both mentioned giftings, whether it be teaching or singing. That seems to be a little more public. That could be easily lumped into performance.
A lot of people are listening. They're like, I don't have those gifts, so I don't have to worry about that. Let me just give you another word. And that word might be production, that we want to get stuff done. We want to produce. We want to serve and lead and accomplish and meet goals.
And like, none of that is inherently bad. But we cannot confuse production for fruitfulness. And the difference goes back to what you were saying, Haley, is what's the source? Abide in me and you will bear much fruit If my relationship with God is what fuels fruitfulness and that's really what's lasting.
And so and I think it's worth bringing in just another emotion, which is just joy. Like do I experience joy? Do I experience here would be a question for everybody to ask two questions. Do I experience more joy doing ministry or in my relationship with God, my personal devotion? And not to confuse those. And again, like you talked about being self aware and honest, and I think that's a really, really adept skill here.
And we probably need some people to to help us. And then the other question just more generally is do I enjoy God and how do I express that enjoyment of him? And if you can answer those questions affirmatively, just like you said, Haley, then you're in a good spot.
But if you're a little confused by that, then you might just need to slow down. You might just need to slow down and really tap into your relationship with God through the spirit and just say, now what's my motive? What's my motive? And and make sure that we don't bring the the self-made mentality too much into our spirituality because it's easy to do. I think even it's a good point about upfront things, I think even just people that are off the stage, I do think it can also be, I think one way you know, you're struggling with this is if you are trying to work something off.
So like, if you're serving because home's not going well but performing, showing up, knocking some things out at church makes you feel better about your inability to be loving and kind at home. So you're making a trade? You're making a trade. Yeah, I think there's an. I think that's another way that performance culture shows up, is we're finding security from our ability to perform as a volunteer, as a leader. You know, it doesn't have to be as a teacher or singer, right?
I think it happens all over. Yeah, we're trying to prove something, maybe not earn something, but definitely seek something. And so we're missing at the core the relationship with God and the way God views us through Christ, Right? Yeah, those are good words, guys. I think we should pivot to our second to the last teaching, which was around sex and happiness. And we kind of previewed this from week one when we talked about desires.
And we said that chief amongst all desires was this notion of sex and happiness. And that's a big topic, Scofield, and, and you did a great job tackling it. But I know that there are several things that you probably wish you could have given more attention to or maybe clarified a little bit.
So this is this is a good forum for that. So what are some thoughts just coming off of that teaching? Yeah. I mean, I think just to zoom out before we zoom in, I mean, it's just, it's what we're trying to say is that, you know, sex is God, God's idea. It's his gift that he gave for a purpose.
And so, you know, it's not, it's not insignificant. It's actually really important like to our spiritual formation, how we react and relate to sex, sexual energy or sexuality. And so that's where the culture is halfway right is it is a big one, right? And it's significant.
And so, but I think the two things that we tried to take away was how you deal with your sexual desires is one of the most important ways that you, your faith is revealed. Frankly, who you believe has the good life, where it comes from, where satisfaction comes from, where fulfillment comes from, and then #2 impacts how we view and how we practice love and how we view other people and the purpose of life. And so with that in mind, I think one of the things that we talked about is how important it is to be known, like for our sexual formation story, our past, our present, our struggles, our temptations, where our desires are conflicting with gods.
And I think that's true. And I think we need to keep saying that, that we need to be known. We need to do what the Bible says, which is live in the light, and that's literally, you know, a way to combat temptation, lies that are so clever, you know, all that.
And so that is true. I think the thing I would wish I had probably said as well is at the same time, no one can obey God for me. So while I need to be known, there's a next step there, which is I got to go figure out if I say I believe that God is good, how is my life going to begin to look more the way that he wants it to? What action steps am I going to take to fight temptation? Flee temptation? A phrase that I used to use with students all the time is to fight the battle before the battle, to be strategic and think about sin is empty.
So therefore I'm going to begin to move in a new route. And I was reading a book recently that talked about disruptive action. And this author said that more change is possible than you would think, but it requires more disruptive action than you would think.
And so let me just say, like for anyone listening to this that's going, I want freedom. I want progress. Like the Holy Spirit is available to us and power and change is possible. And we have to be willing to do more than we might think. Like we got to put the work in, in hidden moments where nobody's watching and no accountability partner can or no church can do anything. You know, for me that God's called me to do because of my faith and my relationship with him.
And so stacking up repetitions of faith and obedience over and over and over again, I think is what unlocks new kinds of momentum towards sexual freedom and transformation. And spiritual maturity, I think about second Peter, one says by God's divine power, he's given you everything you need for living a godly life, everything you need. But he doesn't say he does it for you right now.
And so God doesn't call you just to something without giving you the power and the ability to do. It'd be really cruel if that's what he did and that's not who he is. But he also gives you the option to avail yourself of that power or not, right?
So I think that's a really good distinction. And if I can just say, I think some of this is generational, like I don't, I don't want to speak for the generation that came before me, but it seems like our generation has said we need to talk about these things and why and our feelings and what's going on and what's driving some of this beneath the surface versus just behavior modification. Maybe the pendulum is swinging so far, though, that we're wanting to be known so much that we're not ambitious around what actually going and doing could look like and needs to look like.
And we just it's gonna be a lonely process that's not all that comforting, but it really does like line up with a biblical definition of discipleship, repentance, following Jesus is I gotta go to work on this, you know? Yeah, that's good, Scofield. And diving in a little bit on two specific things that can be a little tricky. Can you talk about both spousal consent and the danger of outsourcing our conscience to the spousal consent and then also revisit the topic of masturbation? Yeah. Those are easy ones.
Let's revisit since that was not miserable to talk about round one. Why not No, we we had a a conversation with a couple pastors about this and that this is a big thing. This goes back to the definition of or the gift like with the Y for the gift that God gave us this gift. What did we say? If you listen to the series for the for the opportunity to love another and to be united with another so that this others oriented love, this service sacrifice to put someone before me and to bring joy and pleasure to them can overflow into fruitfulness in the world.
And so masturbation, like it's a common question. Is it really wrong? Is it something that I shouldn't, you know, and again, it's not that that's not something you can talk about, but it feels like, once again, what are we starting from? What are we thinking about? You know, is this something that I'm entitled this kind of pleasure? And again, it's not that all pleasures bad and our you know, our sexual desires are bad.
It's just, I think once again, we're missing the point. This is not about us self satisfying, self gratifying. This is about something that God gave us to point us to other people and to how we can love them in the context that he gave this gift for. Within that same conversation, the ideas come out.
Well, I mean, take masturbation for example, or looking at inappropriate content or other kinds of things that are outside the bounds. We've had folks at times say, well, it's OK. Like I talked to my wife about it. She's good. Or my husband and I have discussed this and so, and the point is, and so help us understand how that's relevant. How is it that your wife or your spouse is the one who you're outsourcing your conscience to?
Isn't it like God that we're trying to obey here and that we answer to? And who's the one? So I just think we should call that out if, if we have temptation to say, well, as long as the people around me are pleased, then I'm good.
And like, that's really, that's too low of a view. Like we're actually following Jesus and hopefully dragging people around us in that same direction. And so, but it's easy to start to rationalize, justify because, well, it's what I want. What did you just say? We're following Jesus. And what are we doing?
Oh. I don't know what did I say? Dragging other people there with us. Oh, dragging other people. There, I've never heard that, but I really. Yeah, I like that.
Yeah. Again, I, I think you get into this like it's one thing to talk about when you're in a small group, but when you're in your house with your people and you want what you want, right? It is very impressive how we can rationalize and even rally people to our desires. And instead, we should be rallying people to God and Jesus in the like conviction of the Holy Spirit in our life, regardless of what the crowds around us or the people beside me in my bedroom are saying. Yeah, that's a good word.
That's a good word. Who has the ultimate authority? And we did want to take just a moment, I mean, recognizing that we have hundreds, hundreds of singles in our congregations.
And so, Haley, I just wanted to ask if you would speak into this question. So the idea is, if God created us as sexual beings and gives us sexual desires which are good things, but then he doesn't provide the boundaries for that through marriage, then what does sexuality look like for a single if it's not repressed? It's a great question.
Yes, as our single in the room, I will do my best to speak to this. There's a lot of people who are experts more than me, but I'll try to offer a couple of thoughts and I do before I say anything else, I do want to start with a little bit of a compassionate tone because I'm hoping that we're we land with this is actually really motivated and inspired. But I don't want that to come at a cost to recognizing the grief that can come with feeling a desire to connect and to, you know, be in a covenantal relationship on earth and to have a family and all of that.
I mean, that's real grief and that's real loss, especially when that's something that you might have pictured for yourself that's not always promised. So I do recognize that that is painful and I have felt that many times that this is not where I thought my life would be at 29, but it is. And so let me just acknowledge that before I say anything else, that there is a lot of pain there. And it is something that we've got to be willing to not just shove because it feels whatever you want to call it, silly, selfish, consuming, you name it.
I think a lot of times we can push off kind of the death of a dream and and not want to feel it. So I do think we need to acknowledge it. Yeah. Thank you for saying that. Yes.
But with all that said, I think this is a is a powerful concept, but it's not an isolated concept. I think sexual desire and the desire for marriage and for hopefully a family that might come out of that. I think it is a desire and it's a strong desire, but there are a lot of other desires and most people, I would actually say all people don't get all their desires.
So I actually think you can actually elevate this conversation above the actual concept of sex to the idea of desire dream or you know what, you picture expectations for your life in general and just begin to ask the question, OK, well, what is it? How do I respond when a desire is unmet or when I believe that not acting on a desire is the way that I follow God? So I think we can actually find empathy from more people than just single people. I think it can be easy to kind of sometimes create a little insulated bubble where you're spiraling thoughts around a single community sometimes.
But I don't think that we are alone in what we're feeling. I think married people can understand the idea of a desire not being met and not being able to. Exercise every desire that crosses your mind. With that said, I do think there are some unique parts of singleness in this conversation because I mean, what we're saying is that I have a desire that God made me to have that he is asking me not to exercise with, with the without any guarantee that I'll ever get to.
So I think really I, I don't have a ton of new thoughts other than what I've already said about other topics even earlier in this conversation. I think it really does come down to when God and I disagree on something where which choice am I going to make? Am I going to choose him or am I going to choose me? And why am I making that choice? Because all of this sexuality, singleness, and really everything we've covered in this self-made series I think come comes back to Do I believe that the life God has asked us to live is actually the best life a human can live?
Or do I not? And that sounds maybe overly simplified, but for me, I guess with the luxury of getting to think about this material for a year, that's about how I boil it down at this point. Who do I believe has the ticket to the best life for a human? And am I willing to walk that way even if it costs me or if it's difficult or if it means repressing desires sometimes? Who? Whose life do I think is better?
Is it the one that I've scripted for myself or the one that my creator told me is the way that he wants us to live in unity with him? So that's one one way that I kind of think about it again, not to negate the difficulty of it. That sounds almost like a trite statement, but it actually I think does summarize a lot of self-made. The other thing that I've thought about from time to time, it's just the idea that marriage and, and by, you know, by proxy, we're lumping sex and its proper use into that is, as God told us, the symbol of how he relates to his people.
That's the best example we have on earth of the relationship that he desires with us. And though I don't have the symbol and I'm not promised the symbol on this side of heaven, I do have the reality. And my relationship with God is actually the fullness of what marriage symbolizes. And that does not make me feel better most of the time, but every once in a while it does. And I hope that that percentage gets higher over the course of time.
So I think just trying to remember that, that being known, being loved, companionship, sharing dreams together, making each other's gifts, you know, more celebrated. That's the relationship that I get to have with Jesus. If I can try to walk in more close fellowship with him over the course of time, it's a lot harder 'cause he's not physically here. I'm not trying to gloss over that, but the reality of what marriage symbolizes is available to me. I'm not. I might miss out maybe on some things on earth, but I'm not missing out on the eternal by the sake of being single.
So again, that helps occasionally and hopefully more so overtime. Well, that is singing a better song. That's a trying. It's a beautiful effort to sing a better song. And I think that's where we really want people to, once they've understood the context, they get the ideas of self-made, they're able to recognize it. Pervasiveness in the culture, how we drag it into the church.
We turn our attention constantly into singing a better song. So guys, as we just rap, when we think about what Haley just shared a better song and singleness when we think a better song in our life, workplace, home, what other what other ideas, big picture ideas do you guys have when we're thinking about this better song?
One more thought and it's a little bit coming out of singleness, but not entirely. I think in thinking about this content and particularly singleness as the years have gone on, I think getting my head really around the fact that this part on Earth is the short part, that there's there's another part of my existence that's waiting for me. And this part on earth is the shortest part of that. And it's the hardest part of that. If I can really believe that and believe that the intentions of God for what unity and full eternal life with him is going to be, it actually is way better than here, then it gives me a lot of perseverance and grit that sometimes you just got to stick it out through a life that might have a lot of unmet desires and a lot of grief and a lot of tragedy and a lot of self denial.
I mean, that's that's what a life with the war between flesh and spirit inside of us. I think it's the recipe for what we're dealing with. And so if I can actually believe that, am I willing to live my life with a lack? And do I really believe that this is the short part? And if I will stick it out and be faithful that I am headed for an existence that has no disappointment, that has no discouragement, that has no loneliness, none of that, then I really believe that that is as good as he promises and that his character is as good as he promises.
Then no sacrifice and no choice that I make for him on this short little stint of my existence will be a regret to me, I don't think at the end of the day. To answer your question, Scott, about, you know, singing a better song. I mean, for me it's been a lot of the opposite of main character syndrome, you know, like I think about finding joy in the success of others. I think about being a part of God's story, spending time with the main character and learning to say that the box that God gave me is good.
Learning how to embrace my lot in life 'cause there's so much goodness, you know, I guess it makes, I don't know if this is a good way to think about it or not, but when I think about the garden and how there was the knowledge of good and evil and that that from that tree you're not supposed to eat, it is funny to me. Like we point out like why would God do that? Why would God put that in front of them? It's kind of like, but at the same time, he also like said, hey, here's the whole earth, right?
You know, so it's ironic how much we focus on what we don't get. I do think if we could focus more on what we do and then that's different for everybody. Well, I'm going to say that's going to be mine is pushing back against the scarcity mentality and embracing abundance, the abundance that I have first of all in Christ.
But then God has given me so many resources that I, I need to be content and I need to express gratitude. And that's really going to guard my heart in a lot of ways. And then I need to express generosity. And I think a lot of that draws me near to the heart of God as far as singing, singing a better song. And I just want to say like, I think this is the point of the church. Like we could probably pull out a bunch of different scriptural references about how you can connect that concept of singing better song and being a witness to the death, like the what the goal of the church is.
And my thing would be that shouldn't the church be a place where when we say what is a better song look like, you have a bunch of different melodies, a bunch of different, you know, orchestrations and beats and rhythms and instruments? Because all of us are living embodiments of something better than what the world was promising to us. But I think we should be jealous and hungry and experts for it. And, you know, we should be, you know, we should be recording and putting in front of others and celebrating those kinds of stories.
And but you know, it's not easy, like the better song would be happening if it was easy. Like Jesus describes, just let's acknowledge, like he describes his way as narrow and, and you know, but it's the way to life. And so to me, the church should be the hub, right? The rally point where we can say here's what the better song could look like.
Here's what looks like in her and him. And so for me, I'll say one more thing. I just want to be a part of something bigger than me. Like the idea of finding joy in the success of another, whether it's a friend or it's a family member, it's just or it's just our church. That's really beautiful to me. As someone who I've said in the talks is exhausted by a default setting that is worried about me.
Like to be lost in who God is and to be lost in another and to be able to enjoy other humans. I thought that's where we're headed and we could go ahead and get a taste of that today. We can go ahead and start living a little bit more like that now.
Yeah, you stole my answer, Scott. So now I don't know what to say. Dang man, no, I was just going to say I think I think gratitude when I am grateful, when I write those things down and speak those things out loud, it reminds me of God's abundance. And I think for me, one of the way, one of the reasons I don't sing a better song is because I'm moving too fast and I get caught up.
And I think a lot of us are moving a little too fast. And I think if we would slow down long enough to just right now what God's been doing in our life, I actually think we would sing a better song more often. Because how you going to deny when God answers the prayer that you've been praying for for five years? That's a good point.
And so I think some of it is just slowing down enough to see God working. There's this passage in Isaiah. I was talking to Haley about this the other day. It says the people never think about the Lord, so they don't know what he's doing. They don't notice what he's doing. And I think that's, so that's one of the traps.
One of the reasons why we don't sing a better song is because we're so busy all the time, we don't notice what God is up to. And I think if we could just pay attention, get our eyes up and see what he's doing around us, I think it would be easier to combat the lie of the enemy. So that's what I'm trying to do personally is I'm trying to in my home, I want our home to be a place where we are regularly grateful for what God is doing.
And so whether that's little rocks in a jar or a cork board on the wall, whatever corny tool we want to use, like I want me, my wife, my daughters to grow up. And when somebody says, hey, how's God been good to you? Obviously the cross.
But then I want them to have like vivid memories from how God showed up, how God is better, you know. And so I think gratitude is one of the ways that I try to fight this. And it's, it's really helped keep me connected to the abundance of life in Christ. Yeah, this week I was doing some teaching with our interns. We were looking at Matthew 22 and Jesus to the Pharisees, to the Pharisees.
Now he says you don't know the Scriptures, you don't know the power of God. And then he goes on to say, 'cause they're trying to trick him about what's the greatest commandment. And he says love the Lord your God, heart, soul, mind, and strength. Love your neighbor as yourself.
So fully devoted to God and then fully devoted to other people and celebrating their successes and seeing the world through gratitude and having a vision for a future day, the Kingdom of God, the presence of it now and the promise of it in the future. I think those are all parts of our daily practice, what it means to sing this better song. So I'm grateful for all of you. Thank you for your time today. Thank you for your time on this series. And I don't think this is one that we're going to turn the page on.
I think we're going to be here working through these themes for a while. And so I'm really, really grateful for all that. So thank you. Thank you, Scott. Thanks, Scott.