Can I Ask Hard Questions in Church?
Central Generosity
Description
In this episode, Scott is in the studio with Davis Craig and Bobby Raulerson—two teachers from our recent high-school ministry series Hard Questions. True to its title, this series explores topics like: making decisions, the brokenness of the world, doubt and tension, salvation and free will, and more. Bobby and Davis recap the main ideas and explain why a series like this is critical to a healthy student ministry.
- There is no statute of limitations on cultivating the humility to admit when we don’t understand—or the courage to ask good questions.
- We want church to be a safe place to ask hard questions about God, the world, and what Scripture says.
- God engages many difficult topics through his Word, making it—alongside biblical community—our primary resource for seeking answers.
- The Bible doesn’t always offer clear answers to all of our questions, but we can find comfort knowing that God is in control of what we don’t understand.
He's powerful enough and good enough to once again figure out how to weave some of those things that even are broken, some of the suffering that we experience for our own good. And I think for a lot of us, we we've experienced that. We've seen how, OK, this really difficult thing that happened in my life that really was just an expression of evil in the world. God has found a way to use that to help me look more like His Son and experience Him in different ways.
Well, welcome back to the Grace Church Members Podcast. My name is Scott. I'm your host today and I have two first timers here in the studio.
So finally glad we got both Davis Craig and Bobby Rawlerson here around the table. And we're talking student ministry. We're talking some recent content, particularly around asking hard questions.
And so welcome guys, thankful that you're here. Introduce yourselves. And yeah, just tell us a little bit about your connection to student ministry and even your connection to to the Grace Church beyond that.
So, Davis, we'll start with you. Yeah, I, I work here. I work at our Pelham campus, but I'm here today because I also spent a good bit of time thinking about content that are students here centrally. Yeah. And work with a team of folks that work on all of that because honestly, we we produce a handful of things kind of for every series from Fusion all the way up through Forge.
So, so I get to spend a good bit of time thinking about and working on all of that, which is kind of how we arrived our questions. And you've been in the student ministry space for a while now. Yeah, it'll be a decade in a couple. Of months. Wow. On staff.
Yeah. So that's crazy. Yeah. So you're getting old. Yeah, that you. So you've seen this process play out a few different times.
I mean, we're running three different student ministries, lots of series throughout the years and we'll jump into why this specific one. But you've you bring a lot of thought, a lot of knowledge, a lot of experience to this. Tell us a little bit about your family real fast. My wife Madison and I've been married for eight years ish, have three kids, 5, 3 and almost 2.
So we're in it right now, and we care about student ministry being good about a decade for now. Well, that's kind of what I was establishing. Like you've got, you've got pre student ministry kids at home. I mean, you're, you're, you've been around it, but you're seeing where it's going. Bobby, what about you? Tell us a little bit about your background, your relationship to the church.
Sure. Yeah. I started at Grace 2018 in January. That was when I my family and I moved up here and I'm married. My wife Maggie and I have 5 kids. Johnny is 14, Ellie is just turned 11, Annie is 7.
And we have who else? My goodness. It begins to be difficult to name all of the children and all the ages. Ollie is 4. And then we have an 18 month old named Sammy.
So yeah, I'll be like, I don't know, like 60 when he, you know, is, is leaving the house. So we have a lot of kids in our house. We also do care that student ministry is good. And I serve at our Harrison Bridge campus. Discipleship in groups is I'm one of the pastors there.
But recently I've also started to take on some content responsibilities centrally. And so I've been working with Daniel Moore and a team to, to help put together some things like the Essentials Acts series that we're we're kind of launching at some of our campuses. And then I've been working with Davis to talk about student ministry in a lot of different ways.
And so this is one of the cool things that I was able to do was to actually teach one of these messages for our students on hard questions. And so we've just been dialoguing about that for a while now, so. Yeah. No, that's great, Bobby. That's really great. And again, we're glad to have you, have you in the studio.
We're going to have you back because you've got you've got some knowledge on a number of different areas that we want to talk about. But you both mentioned student ministry being good. What makes a good student ministry? That's a good question having honestly, this series in and of itself kind of sums up what I want a student ministry to be, which is not afraid to talk about real things, to address hard questions. Because in preparation for speaking to students about hard questions, I, I came across a study that basically said there are roughly, you know, I'm not sure what roughly 7 out of 10 students after they get out of high school would claim that they had really difficult questions that they never asked while in high school.
Interesting. And about, I would say only one or two of those would actually say something. So really at the end of the day, if you kind of do the math, you got half the students that are in student ministry have hard, difficult questions that they're asking, but they're not actually verbalizing that because they don't feel like they're in a place where they have either leaders or people that care or have answers or want to address those things.
And so I think having a student ministry where vulnerability is on the table, where you have leaders that care and you are able to address real things that the students are processing through and thinking about, that's really for me, what makes a good solid student ministry. Obviously with a a focus on the gospel and making sure we're pointing people to Jesus, but we certainly want to address the real life issues that students are facing. Yeah, we won't meet them where they're at. Absolutely. Yeah.
Davis, what would you add to that? Yeah. I mean, I think, you know, we, we're not confused about the fact that we have less than 2% of the students waking hours generally that we're with them for a week.
And so for us, I mean, we're just, we're trying to maximize that 2% towards a lot of the things that Bobby's talking about. But you know, parents have to ideally be the primary disciple maker of their, of their student. And so for us, we're trying to create community, local church training ground. And that looks different for a 5th and 6th grader, looks different for a 7th and 8th grader. It looks different for a 9th through 12th grader. We're trying to say, OK, this this 5th grader, right?
They're, they're concrete thinkers. They're on the verge of some abstract thought like they're developmentally changing. And that process is going to continue really for till they're like 30.
But for the time that we have, then we're trying to say, OK, how do we train towards what the local church is, what a person that's a part of a local church does that's a follower of Jesus? What, what does their life look like and how do we start giving concrete examples of that that then start to stretch into more abstract things? Because Christianity is it's, it's a lot of abstract thought.
So we're trying to be on the front end of that with our fusion students. We're trying to work through the dark middle school years of 24/7. And then by the time we get to Forge, we really are have an eye towards the future of, OK, this person is going to launch into the real world, whether that's college, workforce, military, something else, right? How is that person going to leave Forge? Having good biblical thoughts about what is the local church, what's biblical community? How do I interact with the Bible?
What is the gospel? And none of that is foreign to them. So they're like, yeah, I'm moving to this new town to go to school and first thing on the list is I got to find a local church that's healthy enough for me to be a part of, start giving my life away at, and be taught the truth and, and all of those things.
So we really are kind of progressively working from a fusion student all the way up through a forge student towards towards that end, yeah. So we're building, we're building, we're meeting students where they are. We're trying to understand the developmental phase both physically, mentally, emotionally and spiritually. OK, so then let's talk about the role of both leaders and parents. We'll we'll, we'll end with parents as we get into particular topic here of hard questions. What makes What makes a good student ministry leader?
A good student ministry leader is a mature Christian, you know, And so I mean a big part of what all of us need is we need people that are beyond us spiritually that can help challenge us, encourage us, care for us in certain moments that are difficult. And so a good leader is, is that they're they're a follower of Jesus who is taking seriously the responsibility that, you know, an organized expression of the Kingdom of God, which we call the local church has spiritual mothers and fathers, spiritual brothers and sisters and spiritual children. And for our leaders like these are their spiritual children where they are mentoring, they're challenging and encouraging with the truth of Scripture.
They're just in space with students. And so a good leader is obviously able to build a relationship with a high school or middle schooler, which can be difficult at times, and but a good leader is able to do that. And then they're just another voice of truth. Ideally, they're not the only voice of truth, right? Their parents are a voice of truth as well, but they're a voice of truth from God's Word and the life of a student. And I mean, we've all been there.
How helpful it can be for for us to hear the same thing from multiple different people because our natural tendency is to disregard one person saying one difficult thing, but all of a sudden two people are saying how I treat my sibling is probably not representative of what Jesus would want. And I'm like, huh, Are both people wrong? Yeah, probably. No.
But I mean, it's just, it makes it a more, you know, it's just, it's kind of how we work. Yeah, more humans, more volume of truth in students lives. Yeah, that's that's a big goal. Bobby, what do you think when you think about your, your, your kids? We'll talk about, like I said, parents in just a second. What?
What kind of leaders have really made an impact your students lives? Sure. I mean, I think that, you know, parents and leaders, as Davis said, are both integral to a student's development, spiritually speaking. I think that for leaders, it's just the willingness to be available, the ability that leaders have to just be there in the moment, ready and willing to have conversations when those things come up. We've all probably tried to pull something out of a teenager. It can be pretty difficult.
I think a lot of the time it's just the be with factor where you're just alongside them, you're doing things with them, you're worshipping with them, you're having conversations, you're there when they don't want to say something, but you're also there when you when they don't want to say something. And so I think it's creating a culture where it's not foreign for students to come up to a leader and ask a difficult question or just say, hey, I'm really struggling with this. And the leader doesn't freak out, doesn't necessarily always have a perfect answer, but is willing to engage in the conversation so that the student knows that they are cared for, they're loved, and that asking questions isn't something that they need to refrain from doing.
Right, which goes back to your your previous data points as you mentioned. Yeah, yeah. It seems to me if we really want to have an effective student ministry, we probably should do it between like 10:00 PM and 11:30 PM When when, when those high schoolers really get ready to talk.
But that's not super practical, speaking as a dad who's raised, raised three of them. While we have you here, Davis, it's we don't want to date this episode too much, but it is retreat season. Just tell us a little bit about the goal of retreats and again, and then we have three different ministries ranging over 7 years.
But what do we hope to accomplish through these retreats? Yeah. You know, retreats have historically just been an incredibly fruitful thing for a bunch of our students for different reasons. I mean, our fusion retreats, like we're just, we're normalizing a little bit of the fact that being a part of God's family is not boring. Like there's, there's a like a more full version of life that even on this side of eternity that Jesus is willing to give us, I think. And, And so for our fusion students, like a lot of it is that what we're trying to, you know, compel them with truths of the gospel.
And, and I know we're going to get into some content thoughts in a second too, but I mean, we're very intentional about what we're teaching on retreats, especially to our middle schoolers, because there's not a ton that has changed about a 12 year old over the last 20 years there. There are some things, right, especially with smartphones and different things, but developmentally, their brain is still in the same place that it was. And so, you know, every other year, like at least once in fusion, you're going to get the gospel over the course of a retreat.
And once the other year you're going to get an understanding and explanation about why our key relationships matter and like how those things play out. And so, and that's, I mean, repetition is helpful. That's what we teach throughout the year to a fusion students in both years that they're there.
So the content doesn't matter as we get away on retreats, but there's something about interrupting the routine, the flow of life, where that kind of disruption creates softer soil that God can really work in. And I mean, that's especially true for our high schoolers and, and middle schoolers is over the last few years, we've started collecting funds on the bus on the way up. And just that disruption, how quickly our brains can except some, some new rhythm that's probably a healthier rhythm on the back end of disconnecting from a phone and just being in space with other people is it's fascinating.
I mean, the detox, the detox is real for much of our students. And so on Friday night, like everybody's kind of, you know, jittery because they haven't had their phone for a couple hours. But then by Saturday night, you know, we're 24 hours in. Everybody is free in a way that I, and they would all admit. I mean, for the most part, they would all admit that no, this is this is different in a good way. And maybe I shouldn't have my phone all the time with right.
But I mean, even that, like just how often can you create that kind of moment? Like it really does take, Hey, we're going to go away for a weekend. That's right. And and do this retreat where we get a chance to, to do some different things and expect that God can meet us in those moments and, and teach us new things.
And so like I said, it's it's proven to be year every year one of the most fruitful things that that we do and. Disrupting the normal routine and creating space like that in of itself is a worthy goal. Then what we do in that space, tons of freedom.
But we try to incorporate lots of elements of fun, lots of elements of community around. There's the existing group, the larger group sometimes, well, we have campuses that are all together, so we're seeing friends from, you know, different schools and different things like that. And then the content is very, very strategic. Yeah.
Just real quickly as you move up through 24/7 and forge, what's what's a forge goal look like as it's different than maybe a fusion goal. On on retreats On retreats. Specifically, yeah. You know, I think that we are working with budding adults and Forge and so that's, that's different than fusion and even sometimes 24/7 students that are on the front end of, OK, what is it? What does it mean to be a young man or young woman made in God's image and all that.
So with Forge, I mean, we are, we are starting to treat them like we would want to treat in a young adult. That's a part of the church because in most cultures throughout history, those they are adults, you know. And so we're we're really not trying to pull any punches from a high school student with the truth. We're trying to meet them where they're at. I mean, a couple of years ago, one thing I think about which we ended up hijacking it for our whole church was self-made. That's that we spent a whole weekend saying, OK, here is here is what your culture is telling you to believe, which is that you're the most important thing.
You're the source of truth. And that's where you know fulfillment comes from is you fully being you. And the Bible just doesn't teach that.
And so, you know, we are, we are very much trying to tackle front edge cultural realities that our students are facing and forge in a way that actually in some ways directs are it can at least direct our adult series. That's a good point because it's a it's like a real live testing ground with ideas that kids are engaging with and being honest about their engagement even though they might not fully form their questions. But, you know, just if you want to know what a kids thinking, just, you know, ask him and he'll tell you.
Maybe ask him a few different times, two different ways. But you learn from those students, and then you start to apply that across different age group seasons of life. Yeah, I've seen that. That's been really, really, really kind of cool to watch.
And so maybe even our content here might have some expression in the future in our adults. We don't know. Because I mean, generationally we are constantly working with a new generation. That's what C Ministry is doing is that, you know, we are constantly working with the new generation that happens to be the next generation of the church.
And so our ability to, you know, share an influence, share the gospel influence with truth and, you know, compel them towards a vision of, of the Bible, of why the Bible is even important is, is a huge deal because that's, that's in some way what we're going to give our next 1020 years to until they are giving their next 1020 years to the next generation, you know. Well, let's let's talk to parents specifically for just a second. And what do we want? Our parents. What do we want our parents to know?
What are we asking them to do in relationship to engagement with their students and how that fits with the overall goals of the student ministry at the churches campuses? Yeah. I think you said something earlier that is helpful, the idea that we're building like we are builders. And I think it's important to know that we really are builders in student ministry, not necessarily fixers, which can be difficult because as a lot of us know, and even some of us have experienced like the middle and high school years can be a moment that is far from God in our lives.
And for parents, I mean, and I remember my parents, I mean, there's, there's a certain amount of control that they want to have that really God is just saying, Oh, you're, you're actually not in charge of that. And so there's just this reality that's playing out where then, you know, as a parent, we want to constrict more and. Say, well, no, I mean, if you just in church more than all of this is going to work out. And no, you have to be a part of this small group and you have to go on this retreat.
And sometimes God totally meets students in that space and then rescues them, but other times he doesn't. And I think the thing that can be helpful to to remember is just that the church is primarily at least student ministries, primarily built around building and being able to say, OK, this is what community looks like. This is what confession looks like. This is what repentance looks like, more so than being the source of salvation, because really only God can do that.
So I do think there's something about that to just be able to note and remember, which is that, you know, God is God is the one that saves. I mean, that's part of the hard questions that even we tackled with our students is, well, who's in tweed gets to choose? Do we get to choose? Does God get to choose? And I think it's important for us to remember God's ultimately in charge. We're just all trying to faithfully obey.
And I think even for our parents, just knowing that we we don't get to control the outcome of salvation for our student. And that's tough because I mean, I'm thinking about it with my three kids and out and I'm like, OK, God, I really want to control where all this goes in their lives, but I can't. All I can do is continue to try to obey the things that you've asked me to do and pray that you will do the same for them. And I have responsibility as a parent and all of that.
But that doesn't guarantee any outcome. And I think student ministry is the same way as there's no guaranteed outcomes in this, right? We are, we are trying to obey God as best as we can and put ourselves in position to be given the truth.
And so I do think there's, there's something about that that feels important to note and and notice. And I mean, I think back to the 2% thing is just that we have such a limited window of time that we're able to influence. And so for parents to remember that like, OK, like we're second string. You know, we really, we, we can come in the game for a second and maybe give a boost of energy and offense and that's great.
But we can't necessarily be in the trenches day in and day out because you can. Yeah, which is a grind that's a lot of hard work. And so I think that even as we talk about leaders, I'm like parents, y'all, y'all are there for a small group leaders, you know, first and foremost, y'all are frustrating and being able to feel that responsibility and not totally want to outsource that to to other people. Other people are going to be a huge part of that, especially as you're I mean for your kids entire life, that's going to be a huge part.
And that's why community is important. But recognizing that OK, there's, there's a limited contribution that can be made outside of our home. So that means we the the pressure is on for us. Yeah, that's a good word. And parents, be encouraged. And just just day by day, make sure that you're understanding and living out the gospel and then just doing the best as you are communicating that kind of truth.
A lot of it is through asking questions and a lot of it is is realizing where we are trying to control. And I think some of that control is why students don't feel like they can ask questions because the parents aren't really giving them the freedom to ask those kinds of questions because these kinds of questions, these are difficult questions that don't necessarily lead to controlled outcomes. Right?
So we've teased it out a good bit here. Tell us exactly these 4 categories. And this is fresh as we just finished this teaching. Sure. With Forge, where? Where did we go and why do we decide to go there?
Yeah, there were 4 main categories where we were asking questions that we knew students were interested in hearing the answers. Making decisions was a big one. Brokenness of the world, right? The problem of evil, which has been around for a long, long time, which is one of the toughest questions that Christians have to have to deal with an answer doubt and tension. You know, what do we do when we have doubt and tension in our relationship with God? How do those things work themselves out and salvation and free will.
Like how do those two things that seem to be a contradiction actually go together and, and what does that look like? So those are the categories that we we had that we dealt with in terms of the hard question series and really. Just small, just small little questions. Yeah, just so really simple, easy questions. Making decisions, brokenness of the world, doubt, intention and salvation and free will. And out of all the questions, tell tell us a little bit about how we kind of came to those 4.
Sure. Well, Michaela Sanders, who works at Harrison Bridge with me, she does student ministry there. She also helps with content centrally for all of our campuses. And she really had this idea of tackling difficult questions that students have.
And so she put some work into surveying a lot of our our high school students. And these were the categories that kept coming up. And so these were the four areas where students just made it really clear we have big questions in these areas that we would love for you to address in a in a teaching series. Awesome. Shout out, Michaela for that. And then what are we hoping to accomplish particularly around destigmatizing these questions?
Yeah, I think for a lot of the students, they need to again, be in a setting where they feel comfortable asking difficult questions, questions that they might not feel comfortable asking. They need to have a culture where that's actually just part of how things operate. But I also think it's important for our parents. We were talking about our parents earlier and their role in discipling their their students. And I think it's, it's interesting because, you know, you get out of high school, you get into college, you know, it's still kind of appropriate for you to ask some of those big, hard, difficult questions.
But then as adults, you get to this place where you're like, can I still ask that question? Because I'm, I'm not sure that I actually have an answer. And I still have thoughts about those things. And, but we feel kind of awkward doing it because we're like, we've been a Christian for a long time.
And so the analogy that I, that I've used is it's like, you know, going to, you know, to church every week and you see the same person, yeah, but you can't remember their name. There becomes a certain amount of time that passes where it's like, OK, it's way too awkward for me to ask that person their name. And I feel like that's the same kind of situation our parents get in where they feel like, I've been around the church for so long, I should have already thought through the problem of evil and not have to ask that question or what does God's will look like and how do I make decisions?
Like I, I feel like I shouldn't be at a place where I have to ask those questions. But what we've realized is that in the same way that students have these questions, parents have these questions as well. Yeah.
So no statue of limitations on asking questions what you're saying? So no, no, that's good. I love that analogy too, because that happens a lot.
So all right, well, we're not going to try to give a thesis on each of these. But what we while we're here and we're in this dialogue and this is fresh, just thought we could take a few minutes and hit the bullet points on on each of these topics. And this is just a fly over. And if you're interested more, we encourage you to ask ask questions. I'm assuming our content that we taught is available. Where's that available, Davis?
It's available on our website. Yeah, so you can find our, you can find this series on our website under Forge Teaching. So Bobby, let's look at the first one on making decisions. Give us some thoughts you have around that. Sure. I think that it's a pretty common question, particularly for high school students.
They're making a lot of decisions. And so the question is really how can I tell whether I'm following God's lead or my own desires when I'm making these decisions? And I, I think there's a really good book that I've read that's been helpful for a lot of students called Just Do Something by Kevin Deyoung. And that book was, was really monumental in terms of helping students understand, OK, what does God's will look like? Because it, it can become tricky. Yeah.
And I think the place to start with this question is with just the nature of God's will. I think God's will is not primarily about finding the right path or discovering the the perfect career or the perfect relationships or the location where I should live. I think it's about becoming the kind of person who reflects Christ in whatever situation you're in.
So in in Romans chapter 12 verses one through 2, those it's a, it's a well known passage about, you know, worshiping the Lord. And it doesn't say discover God's specific plan for your life. It actually says be transformed by renewing your mind and then you'll discern what God's will is.
And so I think that's the key is I remember when I was in high school, actually a guy came in and he was well meaning, but he drew a stick figure on the board. Then he drew God the top right of the board, and he drew a straight line from the stick figure to God. Right? The stick figure was me. Yeah. And then he was like, you're going along.
You're on God's will. But what happens if, like you walk away from God and like where the X was on the line was like my wife. And so it, it terrified me because I'm like, if I step away from the Lord for one second, I might miss my wife or, you know, the decision on where I should go to college.
And so that got me thinking like, what does this actually look like? And I think the illustration that has always stuck with me is kind of like driving on a dark Rd. Like your headlights only go so far, right? And that's the same type of thing. When I think about God's will, it's like he's going to give you enough to see, you know, 100 yards down the road, but he's not going to light the entire thing for you.
And so it's more about trusting him than it is about coming to a point where you have all of the answers. Because we think we want the the high beam highlight and everything. What would happen if we actually saw all that? Oh gosh, I mean it would be overwhelming. No, we couldn't. We couldn't even comprehend it. No.
And there's part of the the relationship that's being cultivated. It's funny, you mentioned Romans. I just we were teaching that in Nicaragua recently and this is a big question that those pastors were asking. And we had the same conversation about the will of God from Romans 12 and just that idea that we want like rules or path because we we long for clarity when really God has given us a relationship. Yeah. And I love that headlight analogy because it's really saying, hey, just the relationship is there.
I'm going to give you the next step. Let's cultivate that relationship and let's keep moving. Yeah, that's great. Yeah, I think not getting bogged down in like there's a, there is one decision that I have to make. I think God, and this might sound a little, a little strange, but it's like, I don't think that God necessarily cares that every single decision that you make is the exact one that he has for you. There was a study a long time ago that I read where it took a playground for kids and they had a fence around it.
They took the fence down and they noticed that when they took the fence down, all of the kids would stay really close to the playground equipment, right? And when they put the fence up, then the kids would like venture off and go play because they were bound. And so I think that God's Word is very clear that there are things that are part of his will and there are things that are not.
And so if your desires are going against God's Word, then that that's the problem, right? God is never going to lead you to cheat or lie or manipulate or justify something that's clearly sinful. But I do think there's room to move. Like I think that there's that boundary of the fence around the playground.
And so you can make decisions and and take certain risks and steps and be in God's will, but it doesn't have to be that linear straight line that we were talking about. Yeah, I'll try not to ask this at with with each of these topics, but how, how was that received by the students? Do you feel like that's resonating? Yeah, I think so. I mean, it's, it's that idea that's just there's there's small things in front of you that you can do every day and that God's got the big picture. Like there's some freedom in that.
And I think for, you know, some of our students, this is AI mean there's a lifelong challenge for a lot of us, right? Absolutely. So for some of those there, it's just good for them. They have a primer.
So now the next time that something happens where they're like, oh gosh, I'm frozen because I don't know what to do. Hopefully God can the Spirit can bring up something from this series and be like, OK, it's OK. I don't have to panic the this decision and that decision, neither one is simple.
So there's probably some freedom in the playground. Yeah, hopefully some freedom. Yeah, that that would be the word that I would would hope for. And because it's very different than the the anxiety that a lot of our students feel and a lot of their students feel that anxiety about pleasing God and staying in God's will.
And so that's a, that's a good word. Anything else you want to add on that, Bobby? I mean, there's a few different things that I think would be helpful, but for the most part, I think it's just about trusting him and and focusing on being the person that he has created us to be. Right? To continue to be discipled, to continue to grow in your relationship with the Lord, to continue to be the kind of person who reflects Christ no matter what situation you find yourself in. I think if we worried more about that and really were we were taking God's word and kind of that was penetrating our heart on a regular basis, then that's going to be the lamp to our feet.
Like that's going to guide our path. That's, that's when the whole, the whole path is not going to be lit up, but enough will be lit up so that we are able to, to continue to follow where the Lord's leading. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Go read Psalm 1 and there's some of a lot of us, There are hundreds of folks right now who are duty doing, reading through the Scripture. And that's where we start. We start in Genesis one.
We start in Psalm One. The idea in Psalm 1 is that we delight in the law of the Lord. We meditate on it, and then we're able to develop deep, deep roots and be like a tree planted by the river.
And so, yeah, stay near to God and his will that that formula becomes a lot easier. So sure. Good, good word there, Davis. Broken, brokenness of the world. Yeah, let's let's go ahead and admit Bobby is way more qualified to speak on all of this than I don't know if I was qualified to teach these, but I did so. You do live.
You live in the world, so you have you're familiar with the brokenness. Yeah, Davis, you can handle this is pretty, pretty simple. Did you ever? Why does evil exist if God is all powerful and all good? Right, Right.
So, so this was, I mean, this is a, this is a tough one because it, it does not take many days breathing to recognize that this world is not right. And you know, it just doesn't, it doesn't take me just read the local news and you can find 6 or 7 stories a week where you're like, how did this person that didn't deserve anything get this death or this sickness or this what I mean, it just does not take long for us to recognize that something seems complicated about this. And so as we tackled this idea of why, why is the world broken?
God's good, all of that. I mean, there's a few things to recognize. 1 is that God created the world good, and it's sin that actually breaks the world. And who who brought sin into the world? Humans did.
And so it's like we created this mess. God didn't create this mess. He gave us freedom to make decisions. He didn't make us robots where we're just operating a code that means we love him and worship him because then that wouldn't be real love or real worship, like there wouldn't be any meaning in that.
So he gave us choice, but that choice created this possibility, right, That we could choose evil. And so I think there is this thing to see Genesis three, OK, who, who, who kind of broke the world. We we actually broke the world. And then what you see from that moment on is that God actually has this commitment to remaking it. He's not good for it to stay broken forever. And while he didn't create it, he can work to he's he does a couple of things that we see throughout the scriptures.
He can work to use things that are not good for our good. Like he figured out a way to say, OK, this isn't great, but I actually can use this for your benefit even though the world is broken and you broke it. So there's this actually incredibly powerful thing about that.
But then ultimately, like he says in Genesis 3, that he kind of alludes to the fact that, no, I'm, I'm really going to solve this. Problem. I got a plan. And and then we get all the way to the end of Revelation and it's like, OK, no, the plan has come to fruition. Like all things are new. Weeping, gnashing of teeth, all that all that's gone.
The brokenness is here no more. And so there's, there's just a handful of things where you see, OK, we, we were responsible for breaking this. It's like my 5 year old, she, she did room time one time we walk in there, she had found a marker at some point and we had some new artwork on our walls. And the point is, is that like she had freedom and within some boundaries to go do something, but she chose to do something that was destructive and not helpful.
Well, then for me, like that was a, that was a clean wall, right? It's a lot of work to find the right paint. We got a magic as we ran out of that paint, got to get the paintbrush out and got to, you know, protect the floor. Like that's what God has been doing ever since is that is a bunch of work to fix the the broken wall, the jacked up wall.
So, so that is what he's been doing and he's powerful enough and good enough to once again figure out how to weave some of those things that even are broken, some of the suffering that we experience for and good. And I think for a lot of us, we, we've experienced that. We've seen how, OK, this really difficult thing that happened in my life that really was just an expression of evil in the world. God has found a way to use that to help me look more like his son and experience him in different ways.
So. I love that you, you start with the biblical story because I think that's the place to start with this question. Because I think a lot of times people believe that Christianity just kind of offers this type philosophical formula, but it it doesn't what Christianity offers is it offers a story.
And so the world obviously created good like you mentioned, but then evil entered not as something that God created, but as as a distortion of good and trying to like wrap my mind around that. I think of, I think of like a parasitic type relationship or even even like rust, Like rust doesn't exist without metal. So really evil is a privation of good. Like if there was no metal, there would be no rust, right?
And so because there's good, there can be evil, but God is not the one that created the evil, but he's the one that's going to then take it, allow it, but he doesn't endorse it, if that, if that makes sense. So I do like the fact that we started with the the biblical story rather than going straight to kind of like philosophical conversation out of the gate. Well, and even thinking about the character of God right after that event in Genesis 3, you know, there's consequences for sin and then there's a plan to deal with it.
Right, Romans. 5 And that's where we get just the the the new Adam in Romans 5, in Christ in the first gospel in Genesis chapter 3, and just the story of Joseph. Again, thinking through where a lot of a lot of our church is right now, reading through the Scripture in Genesis, Joseph, clear example of what was meant for evil, God turned for good. And so we can see a lot of those examples throughout Scripture. Yeah, those are big ideas, guys. It sounds like you did a really, really good job.
But all about anything else. 01 Other thing I think that's important to mention is that obviously evil and suffering are real, and we see that, as Davis alluded to, every day and the evil is devastating. I think God doesn't minimize that, but he's not powerless and he's not indifferent. I think the the word we're looking for is he's patient.
So why does he allow this to continue? In Second Peter 319, that passage reminds us that God delays judgment because he desires repentance. Like he could end all of the suffering, the evil in the world, but that would require judgment. And he's patient and desires all people to repent.
And so there is a, a piece to this word. Like, I don't know how long that that patience is going to, to last. That's not our call. That's not information that we get.
But I do think that when the question is why does God allow this? He, he allows it in in a sense, because he's patient and he wants people to repent. Yeah, from the evil that they've turned to. And I think finding that, finding that balance in that tension, because a lot of our high schoolers, they're going through difficult things. Yeah. They're going through the effects of the brokenness of the world.
They're going through disappointment, you know, disease, sickness, death. I mean, they're, they're they're, they're living life as these emerging adults. Like we were talking about specifically, I'm thinking about our sixteen 1718 year olds. And I'm also I'm just have this picture you know, of we talked about getting desensitized to things, but are are kids that are going to public high school like they're walking through metal detectors every day when they go into high school. And they're they're just that they're living with the reality of the brokenness of the world all all around them.
And for our leaders to be really empathetic with these questions. Sure. Because of the effects of sin in the lives of everyday students and not try to come up with trite answers that that don't that don't really solve the problem. Yeah. And I think going back to what you just said, like go to the scriptures to both define the problem, talk about the solution, and part of that solution is found in this ongoing relationship and intention with God being sovereign and whatever his eternal plan is. Yeah.
And and then having the comfort of of not having to do it alone. I think that's that's a big part. So it's our third topic is about doubt intention. And and sure, the brokenness of the world contributes to to some of that doubt intention. It's not the only thing that does.
But Bobby, how did you, how did you kind of handle that? Yeah, this was the message that I that I taught for our forge students was on doubt and tension. And I looked specifically at Job chapter 42, verse 7 and I I really kind of unpacked job the entire book quickly succinctly for the students.
But I I remember starting just with a story of of my own one from when I was in high school. I had a, a good friend named Elaine who, who passed away unexpectedly. She was driving to work, a guy coming the other direction had a heart attack, swerved in her lane and and she passed away on the scene.
And so that to me was the definition of pointless. Like she's 16 years old. She has her entire life ahead of her. If that if that man's heart attack would have happened 30 seconds before, 30 seconds after, she still would be here.
And so that began the process of, of me kind of just shoving difficult questions and doubt and tension down because I didn't really feel like I had a place to talk about it. And I used the illustration of a beach ball. Like, it's possible for you to get into the swimming pool and hold a beach ball underwater. Like, it's not difficult.
But over time, like you, you move your hands at all and that thing is going to going to explode to the surface. Yeah, it's going to, it's going to come to the surface. And for me, that happened when I was in seminary. I had the kind of a crisis of faith because of all of this doubt and tension that I had been shoving down trying to manage these, you know, these beach balls, so to speak, under the water. And I just couldn't do it anymore. And they just all came to the surface and I began to understand, like, obviously just silence isn't the answer.
Not talking about doubt, intentions is certainly not the answer. That's the beach ball approach. That's never going to work.
But for our students, what I wanted them to see is #1A story in Scripture that we have with the person of Job who did nothing wrong, right, did not do anything to deserve what, what he walked through. That was actually the result of Satan going before the Lord, saying, you know, God saying, have you considered my servant Job? He, the only reason he follows you is because you're, you know, you give him everything he wants, right? Like that's easy.
And so everything was stripped from him. And what was fascinating to me is, as I read through the whole book of Job, just in preparation for that talk, is that you get to the end and of course you hear Joe being very raw with God. And then you hear Joe's friends who are talking a lot about God. And their theology is very simplistic. It's like good people get good things, bad people get bad things, so you must have done something. Right.
Well, and you. Yeah, how often does that theology creep into our? Our thoughts. Oh, absolutely. And so what's interesting is when you get to the end of Job chapter 42, verse 7, God makes it very clear, like I'm angry with your friends because they did not speak accurately about me.
But then he says, but Job did speak accurately about me, which was kind of mind blowing because Job does not mince words. He, he is, you know, the day of my conception, I wish you would just like basically throw it into utter darkness. I mean, he was just, it was rough. It was rough. I mean, you see him just weeping before the Lord sack off and ashes, like the whole, the whole deal. And the reason I think that God said that he actually spoke accurately about him is because Job refused to walk away from God in terms of the conversation.
He was speaking to God. And So what I kind of laid out for the students is that there are three ways that we can really deal with doubt and tension. There's the silence, there's the beach ball approach. There's you can talk about God, which a lot of people do, right? That's what I was doing in seminary. I was doing a lot of talking about God.
And that can sound really spiritual, religious, theological. Problem is I wasn't doing a lot of talking to God and so Job was talking to God. And so the, the encouragement there is I don't, I don't care what your doubt is or the tension that you're involved in. Even going back to what we just talked about the evil and suffering in the world. Are you talking to God about those things or you just talking about God, right. And that's really the the question that I had for them.
I encourage them to really bring those difficult doubts, intentions to the Lord and have conversations with him about them rather than just talking about it with friends or or other people. Clearly we want community support us in the midst. So I'm not saying don't ever talk to anybody else about it, just talk to God.
But I do think that that's what's missing is the is bringing it before the Lord and refusing to walk away from that conversation saying I don't understand and I'm frustrated. I don't get it, but I I'm trusting you and I'm here and I'm talking. Yeah, Job had community. Yeah, but he didn't have biblical wisdom around him. No. Yeah, absolutely.
That's a good word. That's a really good word. Anything you want to add to that, Davis? No, I mean, I think one thing that Bobby helped our students with a lot was just recognizing the gap between God being good. And I mean, he really went back to brokenness of the world, but saying there's this gap between God being good and the evil that we experience and the bat. That's kind of the core tension that we really feel.
And the solution isn't more answers, it actually is faith. And so there's just this piece where we have to recognize that, OK, God is God and I am not, and that is OK. And that doesn't mean that all of this, all of this is OK, but it does mean that I can be OK like in the midst of this because I, I can have faith in him who created this and will fix all of this. Yeah, I'm not a big like equation type guy when it comes to spirituality for sure.
But I think if there is an equation to like, think about when terms of your relationship with the Lord and when you have doubt and tension and those things in your life, I think that it's to practice emotional honesty, but with spiritual humility. I think that that's the tension. It's like we, we want to be honest with the Lord because God is not afraid of our emotions.
So we want to be honest with where we are emotionally, but then we also want to spiritually be humble. And, and I think that was really, was really what I saw in Job is he was very clear about not understanding what was going on or being frustrated by it and, and just being like what in the world? But he also, he, he also humbled himself when God comes out and starts, where were you when I formed the like, what he was like, all right, he's like, OK. And I think that's kind of the the mindset we need to have when we're going to the Lord, just like we don't need to hide emotions from him as if he can't see those things, but we certainly do need to humble ourselves and realize that he is sovereign and the creator of of, of all.
So. There is a God. You're not him. Yeah, one of the very first things we we teach our elementary students right. Yep. And and that is a a through line here, but really prominent in our last topic salvation and free will.
So I'm glad you were able to put that one to wreck Davis. Yeah, we've been great time we've been waiting for, I don't know, couple thousand 1000. Yeah, we just stopped. We just stopped talking about it, Al started. To tell us how you wrap that up in a bow for our students. Yeah, very easily.
No, this is funny because I mean, this is one of those things that it just like for me, the world that I grew up in, predestination was like a Christian cuss word. Like you don't say that because that's not even really true. So I remember getting to college and like I had never really read my Bible.
So right, that's a tough spot to be in. And and I was at lunch with Clark Merritt because our downtown campus and I remember saying, like, man, predestination, that's ridiculous. That's not true and he was he took me to Ephesians 1/5 and he's like, hey, you literally know the word is the word is in your Bible libel. And I was like, huh, now that is an interesting point. And the. Word Trinity is not, but the word representation is, Yeah.
So like for me that was that was actually a huge moment where I was like, OK, one, I probably should read my Bible some that would help me a good bit. And two, just that this is not, it's not cut and dry how we kind of want to make it at times. And so, I mean, the answer is the answer is yes, Scott. Yes, Both predestination and free will are real.
So what we did is we kind of went through and just made a case from Scripture for both, for both ideas to say, OK, like you can clearly look at Ephesians and see that God chose. He knew all of this before the world was formed. And he chose who was going to be a part of his family, who were going to be his children, who's going to be adopted. You see it in Romans. You see it multiple times where it's like, OK, God, God before the foundations of the earth, God knew, God chose. Nothing surprises him.
And so there's this truth where God is in control. Nothing surprises him, especially our salvation, whether or not we, you know, follow him or not. Like it's not surprising to him.
But at the same time, you go to the Scriptures and you read other passages and I love and Deuteronomy where it's the end of Deuteronomy where Moses is basically like laying out the options they have before them. And it's just like you choose and I hope you make the right choice. And it's like, well, if God was made, if God was in charge and control and nothing surprised him, then why wouldn't he just make the right choice for you?
But it's like, no, like you have to make the right choice. And your ancestor, I mean, you're generations beyond this will either benefit or suffer from the choices that you make around all this. And it's just this super interesting thing. And you mentioned where Peter's talking about it, where he's like, God is being slow because he wants everyone to be saved as kind of the idea he don't want anyone to be destroyed. And you're like, well, if God was in charge and he didn't want anyone to be destroyed, well, then Bing bang, boom, let's, let's wrap it up right now.
You know, so it's like clearly, OK, our, our choices matter. We have choices to make and those choices matter. And so the scriptures just they hold both things out as true. They don't, they don't even really pit them against each other. They're just like, no, both things are obviously true.
So we're. We're the ones that pit them. But we put them against each other because what we have finite brains and, and there's this thing where we desire to be able to comprehend something, right, to be able to understand how something exists and relates to everything else. And we just, we actually don't have that capacity, right? If we did have that capacity, we'd be God. Yeah.
And it competes with faith, with the idea of faith. Yeah, Yeah. And so for us, I mean, we, we have to be able to hold these two things and say, OK, we are creatures, We're not the creator. There's a God, we're not him, right? We start, I mean, we teach fusion students that from day one, but there's a God and I'm not him. And that, that means that I don't understand how these, the two things work together.
And so there's, there should be this comfort that comes from the fact that God's in control. Nothing surprises him. And we should be able to kind of take that. We should be able to take comfort in that.
But then there's this reality of this responsibility that we have that our our choices are real and they do matter. And how those two things married, I mean, maybe God will explain that to us in eternity, but maybe not. But still not. We still want. Yeah, I don't think we're going to care too much. Yeah, Right.
But no, that's great. That's a, that's a, that's really, really helpful. And I'm so glad you, you, you tackled that. And I always think about this anecdote because this is a seminary story and and if you're going to get this answer, answer to this question, surely it's going to be in seminary, right?
And so we had AI had a wonderful mentor, Howard Hendricks, who was it's kind of the, the father of Bible study methods and everybody loved him. He was kind of the father of the seminary. And so he would make himself available to the young man that we're living in the, the single man's dormitory. He'd go over on Friday night and they'd have pizza and it was just like as Prof everything and you know, and he, he would laugh and he would say every Friday night the conversation is the same. We start out trying to solve predestination and free will.
And then we end the night trying to find, talking about how to find a wife. And he said, so we start here. But really this is the relational aspect of applying faith in life is really where everybody is living. And I'm like, you know, that feels like ministry in the church too. We have all these big questions, but at the end of the day, like I'm just trying to make it through today to the next thing and you guys covered a lot of that in these big questions.
So thanks for doing this. Yeah. Any closing thoughts on you know what you hope to to to be the the the the catalytic moment coming out of out of this series? No, I mean, I think, I think what we've been talking about, which is the fact that it's OK to have hard questions. Yeah. And the place to go with those hard questions is the Scriptures and community, and you ought to stuff it down.
And Davis Craig's e-mail and my e-mail D Greg at grace dot SZ be happy to well, thanks. Thanks for listening to to this. Hopefully you got some insight into student ministry. Got a little window into a recent series. If you have Forge students, ask them how it went. If you know Forge leaders, just encourage them that they're doing good work and and if you want to be involved in student ministry, there are places for you to jump in and get involved.
And we would love to love to talk talk with you about that. Bobby, will you just close our time on this idea of just trusting God, being able to ask questions, spiritual humility? Will you just just pray for us? Sure. Father, we are thankful that you are a God who is sovereign in control. We are thankful that we cannot wrap our minds around you because if that was the case, then then you wouldn't be gone.
And so we are, we are recognizing and admitting that there are hard, difficult questions that we have as believers, but that you are God that invites conversation, that has given us your word, that has revealed yourself to us, and you've revealed our need for you. And so we just asked that we would cling to that, that we would just be overwhelmed and in awe of your gospel each and every day. We ask for our students who are kind of struggling with some of these things. And even our parents are adults that are, that are still having questions and wanting to to kind of get to the bottom of things that ultimately at the end of the day, Lord, that we all would just be putting our faith in you and that we'd be continuing to take one step closer to you and continuing to grow in your likeness.
And so we again, thank you for what you've done through this series for our students. And we ask that you would just continue that work, particularly as we get into retreat month in Christ, I may pray. Amen.